Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
Results 31 to 35 of 35

Thread: Seti scientists announce that a clearly artificial signal has been identified...

  1. #31

    Mary Doria Russell wrote a fascinating novel about a scenario very much like the one described in the OP. The Sparrow won the Arthur C. Clarke, James Tiptree, Kurd-La▀witz-Preis, John Campbell and the British Science Fiction Association awards.

 

  • #32
    Quote Originally Posted by Klaus View Post
    Okay, here's a change to the scenario:

    Seti scientists announce that a clearly artificial signal has been identified...

    ... it comes from just beyond the orbit of Pluto!!

    Now, what ?
    I guess every telescope is turned in this direction to see what it is... If it's some kind of probe (think an alien "voyager" or "pioneer" probe), then we probably have a very short amount of time to catch it. If it's something bigger... See Rama I or II.

    As for the original post, it was about some kind of electromagnetic signal (radio waves, laser...). I choose a few thousands light years away so that we can be sure this event has no imminent consequence, and we have no way of establishing communication : I'm only interested in the consequences (political, philosophical, religious, scientific, social...) of knowing for sure that "there was someone there".

  • #33
    Quote Originally Posted by Aloysius View Post
    I guess every telescope is turned in this direction to see what it is... If it's some kind of probe (think an alien "voyager" or "pioneer" probe), then we probably have a very short amount of time to catch it. If it's something bigger... See Rama I or II.

    As for the original post, it was about some kind of electromagnetic signal (radio waves, laser...). I choose a few thousands light years away so that we can be sure this event has no imminent consequence, and we have no way of establishing communication : I'm only interested in the consequences (political, philosophical, religious, scientific, social...) of knowing for sure that "there was someone there".
    What if the source of the signal is on a synchronous orbit on the far side of Pluto, meaning no Earth-based telescope can see it?

  • #34
    Quote Originally Posted by Klaus View Post
    What if the source of the signal is on a synchronous orbit on the far side of Pluto, meaning no Earth-based telescope can see it?
    How can we detect something from it if that so ? *not a radio-astronomer spikey*.

  • #35
    I'm sad to say I agree with the opinion that the OP scenario won't change much. I personally would be immensely interested, but it won't really touch the lives of most of humanity. If it would make a difference, it would be in being yet another contributing element towards trends of space exploration and a pan-consciousness (pro animal rights and so on) morality. The affect on the world's religions would be minute.

    Quote Originally Posted by Rusty Halo View Post
    Mary Doria Russell wrote a fascinating novel about a scenario very much like the one described in the OP. The Sparrow won the Arthur C. Clarke, James Tiptree, Kurd-La▀witz-Preis, John Campbell and the British Science Fiction Association awards.
    One of the most unnerving books I've ever read. It was just... creepy, in a macabre, dark way.
    "Respect and obey the laws of gravity, cause and effect, relativity, etc. ... It's not that hard."
    - Talmud of Jmmanuel Advocate, posting seriously.

  • Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123

    Posting Permissions

    • You may not post new threads
    • You may not post replies
    • You may not post attachments
    • You may not edit your posts
    •